Rank LP's Albums

Discussion in 'Linkin Park Chat' started by LeoMPhillyFan, Aug 25, 2012.

  1. #1
    LeoMPhillyFan

    LeoMPhillyFan Well-Known Member

    Joined:
    Apr 15, 2012
    Messages:
    168
    Likes Received:
    1



    On a recent thread comparing Meteora to Living Things, I posted a comment that compared the two albums mathematically by grading each song out of 10 and then adding up the scores. Quite a few people followed my lead and did the same thing. I'm really curious to see how people would grade every album. One other note, because not all LP albums have the same number of tracks rank them by percentage points. P.S. Your welcome to grade Reanimation and the interludes/instrumentals on the studio albums that I personally skipped.

    Hybrid Theory EP
    Carousel 8/10
    Step Up 8/10
    And One 9/10
    High Voltage 7/10
    Part Of Me/Ambient 9/10

    Total: 41/50

    Hybrid Theory
    Papercut 10/10
    One Step Closer 9/10
    With You 9/10
    Points Of Authority 9/10
    Crawling 9/10
    Runaway 5/10
    By Myself 6/10
    In The End 10/10
    A Place For My Head 9/10
    Forgotten 7/10
    Pushing Me Away 9/10

    Total: 92/110

    Meteora:
    Don't Stay: 7/10
    Somewhere I Belong: 7/10
    Lying From You: 9/10
    Hit The Floor: 6/10
    Easier To Run: 4/10
    Faint: 9/10
    Figure .09: 8/10
    Breaking The Habit: 10/10
    From The Inside: 7/10
    Nobody's Listening: 7/10
    Numb: 8/10

    82/110

    Minutes To Midnight
    Given Up 7/10
    Leave Out All The Rest 9/10
    Bleed It Out 8/10
    Shadow Of The Day 8/10
    What I've Done 6/10
    Hands Held High 6/10
    No More Sorrow 7/10
    Valentines Day 6/10
    In Between 5/10
    In Pieces 9/10
    The Little Things Give You Away 9/10

    80/110

    A Thousand Suns
    Burning In The Skies 6/10
    When They Come For Me 9/10
    Robot Boy 6/10
    Waiting For The End 10/10
    Blackout 8/10
    Wretches And Kings 8/10
    Iridescent 8/10
    The Catalyst 9/10
    The Messenger 5/10

    69/90

    Living Things:
    LOST IN THE ECHO: 9/10
    IN MY REMAINS: 9/10
    BURN IT DOWN: 7/10
    LIES GREED MISERY: 7/10
    I'LL BE GONE: 7/10
    CASTLE OF GLASS: 7/10
    VICTIMIZED: 8/10
    ROADS UNTRAVELED: 7/10
    SKIN TO BONE: 7/10
    UNTIL IT BREAKS: 6/10
    TINFOIL/POWERLESS: 8/10

    82/110

    1. Hybrid Theory 84%
    2. Hybrid Theory EP 82%
    3. A Thousand Suns 77 %
    4. LIVING THINGS 75%
    LIVING THINGS earns the tiebreaker because it is more diverse and has better lyrics than Meteora.
    5. Meteora 75%
    6. Minutes To Midnight 73%

    One flaw in ranking this way is albums with less tracks usually get an advantage as there is less chance for mediocre to bad songs to weigh down the scores. For example, I like LIVING THINGS and Meteora better than Hybrid Theory EP and A Thousand Suns; but in this ranking they're lower.
     
    Last edited: Aug 27, 2012
  2. #2
    lime treacle

    lime treacle You are not alone Über Member

    Joined:
    Jul 19, 2011
    Messages:
    10,907
    Likes Received:
    1,791



    I don't have the will to do all that. :lol:
     
  3. #3
    Suffered

    Suffered All we need is faith

    Joined:
    Jun 29, 2012
    Messages:
    521
    Likes Received:
    3



    Hybrid Theory EP
    Carousel 7/10(Post-EP demos are way better)
    Step Up 8/10
    And One 7/10(It's much better live)
    High Voltage 5/10(This version sucks)
    Part Of Me 5/10(Same as Carousel)

    Hybrid Theory
    Papercut 10/10
    One Step Closer 7/10
    With You 9/10
    Points Of Authority 9/10
    Crawling 9/10(Where's the rap part from the demo?)
    Runaway 7/10(Stick 'N Move 7.5/10)
    By Myself 7/10(SuperXero 10/10)
    In The End 7/10
    A Place For My Head 9/10(Esaúl 9.5/10)
    Forgotten 7/10(Rhinestone 9/10)
    Pushing Me Away 9/10

    Meteora:
    Don't Stay: 2/10
    Somewhere I Belong: 0/10
    Lying From You: 3/10
    Hit The Floor: 6/10
    Easier To Run: 2/10
    Faint: 6/10
    Figure .09: 2/10
    Breaking The Habit: 7/10
    From The Inside: 2/10
    Nobody's Listening: 6/10
    Numb: 0/10

    Minutes To Midnight
    Wake 8/10
    Given Up 8/10
    Leave Out All The Rest 10/10
    Bleed It Out 10/10
    Shadow Of The Day 10/10
    What I've Done 9/10
    Hands Held High 9/10
    No More Sorrow 8/10
    Valentines Day 9/10
    In Between 10/10
    In Pieces 10000000/10
    The Little Things Give You Away 10/10

    A Thousand Suns
    The Requiem/The Radiance 9/10
    Burning In The Skies 10/10
    When They Come For Me 10/10
    Robot Boy 10/10
    Waiting For The End 10/10
    Blackout 10/10
    Wretches And Kings 7/10
    Iridescent 10/10
    The Catalyst 10000000/10
    The Messenger 10/10

    Living Things:
    LOST IN THE ECHO: 7/10
    IN MY REMAINS: 10000000/10(I can't hear the fuckin synth)
    BURN IT DOWN: 8/10
    LIES GREED MISERY: 7/10
    I'LL BE GONE: 7/10
    CASTLE OF GLASS: 10000000/10
    VICTIMIZED: 8/10
    ROADS UNTRAVELED: 10000000/10
    SKIN TO BONE: 10/10
    UNTIL IT BREAKS: 10/10
    TINFOIL/POWERLESS: 10/10
     
  4. #4
    Melis

    Melis when you're feeling empty, keep me in your memory LPA Super Member

    Joined:
    Jun 21, 2012
    Messages:
    5,505
    Likes Received:
    123



    Hybrid Theory EP
    Carousel 7/10
    Step Up 9/10
    And One 7/10
    High Voltage 8/10
    Part Of Me 6/10

    Total: 36/50

    Hybrid Theory
    Papercut 7/10
    One Step Closer 8/10
    With You 8/10
    Points Of Authority 10/10
    Crawling 8/10
    Runaway 10/10
    By Myself 5/10
    In The End 8/10
    A Place For My Head 9/10
    Forgotten 7/10
    Pushing Me Away 9/10

    Total: 89/110

    Meteora:
    Don't Stay: 5/10
    Somewhere I Belong: 8/10
    Lying From You: 8/10
    Hit The Floor: 4/10
    Easier To Run: 6/10
    Faint: 9/10
    Figure .09: 7/10
    Breaking The Habit: 10/10
    From The Inside: 7/10
    Nobody's Listening: 7/10
    Numb: 6/10

    77/110

    Minutes To Midnight
    Given Up 8/10
    Leave Out All The Rest 10/10
    Bleed It Out 9/10
    Shadow Of The Day 8.5/10
    What I've Done 10/10
    Hands Held High 8/10
    No More Sorrow 7/10
    Valentines Day 7.5/10
    In Between 7/10
    In Pieces 9/10
    The Little Things Give You Away 8/10

    85/110

    A Thousand Suns
    Burning In The Skies 10/10
    When They Come For Me 10/10
    Robot Boy 9/10
    Waiting For The End 10/10
    Blackout 9/10
    Wretches And Kings 8/10
    Iridescent 10/10
    The Catalyst 10/10
    The Messenger 7/10

    83/90

    Living Things:
    LOST IN THE ECHO: 10/10
    IN MY REMAINS: 8/10
    BURN IT DOWN: 7/10
    LIES GREED MISERY: 7/10
    I'LL BE GONE: 7.5/10
    CASTLE OF GLASS: 8.5/10
    VICTIMIZED: 8/10
    ROADS UNTRAVELED: 10/10
    SKIN TO BONE: 7/10
    UNTIL IT BREAKS: 7/10
    TINFOIL/POWERLESS: 7/10

    87/110

    Hybrid Theory EP 72%----> 5.
    Hybrid Theory 80%-----> 2.
    Meteora 70%------> 6.
    Minurtes To Midnight 77%---> 4.
    A Thousand Suns 92%----> 1.
    LIVING THINGS 79%------> 3.
     
  5. #5
    Blake

    Blake Leave a Trace LPA Super Member

    Joined:
    Mar 25, 2012
    Messages:
    8,284
    Likes Received:
    2,238



    Hybrid Theory EP
    Carousel 8/10
    Step Up 8/10
    And One 10/10
    High Voltage 5/10
    Part Of Me 10/10

    Total: 41/50

    Hybrid Theory
    Papercut 10/10
    One Step Closer 10/10
    With You 9/10
    Points Of Authority 9/10
    Crawling 10/10
    Runaway 8/10
    By Myself 7/10
    In The End 10/10
    A Place For My Head 10/10
    Forgotten 8/10
    Pushing Me Away 10/10

    Total: 101/110

    Meteora:
    Don't Stay: 10/10
    Somewhere I Belong: 10/10
    Lying From You: 10/10
    Hit The Floor: 7/10
    Easier To Run: 10/10
    Faint: 10/10
    Figure .09: 10/10
    Breaking The Habit: 10/10
    From The Inside: 10/10
    Nobody's Listening: 10/10
    Numb: 10/10

    107/110

    Minutes To Midnight
    Given Up 10/10
    Leave Out All The Rest 10/10
    Bleed It Out 10/10
    Shadow Of The Day 8/10
    What I've Done 10/10
    Hands Held High 8/10
    No More Sorrow 7/10
    Valentines Day 10/10
    In Between 10/10
    In Pieces 10/10
    The Little Things Give You Away 8/10

    101/110

    A Thousand Suns
    Burning In The Skies 8/10
    When They Come For Me 10/10
    Robot Boy 4/10
    Waiting For The End 10/10
    Blackout 10/10
    Wretches And Kings 10/10
    Iridescent 8/10 (used to like it a lot more)
    The Catalyst 10/10
    The Messenger 7/10 (used to like it a lot more)

    77/90

    Living Things:
    Lost in the Echo: 10/10
    In My Remains: 10/10
    Burn It Down: 10/10
    Lies Greed Misery: 10/10
    I'll Be Gone: 10/10
    Castle of Glass: 10/10
    Victimized: 10/10
    Roads Untraveled: 10/10
    Skin to Bone: 10/10
    Until It Breaks: 9/10
    TINFOIL/POWERLESS: 10/10

    109/110


    Hybrid Theory EP 82%----> 5.
    Hybrid Theory 92%-----> 3
    Meteora 97%------> 2.
    Minurtes To Midnight 92%---> 3
    A Thousand Suns 86%----> 4.
    LIVING THINGS 99%------> 1.

    and the stats came out exactly my rankings as well so that's awesome.
     
  6. #6
    Ben

    Ben Well-Known Member

    Joined:
    Sep 26, 2009
    Messages:
    968
    Likes Received:
    165



    Hybrid Theory:

    1) Papercut - 10/10
    2) One Step Closer - 7/10
    3) With You - 6/10
    4) Points of Authority - 8/10
    5) Crawling - 8/10
    6) Runaway - 8/10
    7) By Myself - 4/10
    8) In The End - 9/10
    9) A Place For My Head - 9/10
    10) Forgotten - 6/10
    11) Cure For the Itch - 7/10
    12) Pushing Me Away - 8/10

    Total: 90/120 - 75%


    Meteora:

    1) Foreward/Don't Stay - 8/10
    2) Somewhere I Belong - 7/10
    3) Lying From You - 10/10
    4) Hit The Floor - 6/10
    5) Easier To Run - 9/10
    6) Faint - 10/10
    7) Figure.09 - 8/10
    8) Breaking The Habit - 10/10
    9) From The Inside - 9/10
    10) Nobody's Listening - 4/10
    11) Session - 7/10
    12) Numb - 9/10

    Total: 97/120 - 81%


    Minutes To Midnight:

    1) Wake - 7/10
    2) Given Up - 8/10
    3) Leave Out All The Rest - 9/10
    4) Bleed It Out - 9/10
    5) Shadow of the Day - 4/10
    6) What I've Done - 8/10
    7) Hands Held High - 4/10
    8) No More Sorrow - 7/10
    9) Valentine's Day - 7/10
    10) In Between - 5/10
    11) In Pieces - 7/10
    12) The Little Things Give You Away - 8/10

    Total: 83/120 - 69%


    A Thousand Suns:

    1) The Requiem/The Radiance - 10/10
    2) Burning In the Skies - 8/10
    3) Empty Spaces/When They Come For Me - 9/10
    4) Robot Boy - 3/10
    5) Jornada Del Muerto - 7/10
    6) Waiting For the End - 8/10
    7) Blackout - 5/10
    8) Wretches and Kings - 7/10
    9) Wisdom, Justice, and Love/Iridescent - 10/10
    10) Fallout/The Catalyst - 9/10
    11) The Messenger - 5/10

    Total: 81/110 - 74%


    Living Things:

    1) Lost in the Echo - 8/10
    2) In My Remains - 9/10
    3) Burn It Down - 10/10
    4) Lies Greed Misery - 6/10
    5) I'll Be Gone - 10/10
    6) Castle of Glass - 9/10
    7) Victimized - 9/10
    8) Roads Untraveled - 8/10
    9) Skin to Bone - 6/10
    10) Until It Breaks - 5/10
    11) Tinfoil/Powerless - 7/10

    Total: 87/110 - 79%


    FINAL RESULTS:
    1) Meteora - 81%
    2) Living Things - 79%
    3) Hybrid Theory - 75%
    4) A Thousand Suns - 74%
    5) Minutes To Midnight - 69%

    This is the exact order I would've ranked the albums as a whole anyways.
     
  7. #7
    RiseFromTheAshez

    RiseFromTheAshez Banned

    Joined:
    Jun 20, 2010
    Messages:
    115
    Likes Received:
    0



    Hybrid Theory EP
    Carousel 9/10
    Step Up 8/10
    And One 10/10
    High Voltage 8/10
    Part Of Me 9/10

    Total: 44/50 - 88%


    Hybrid Theory:

    1) Papercut - 9/10
    2) One Step Closer - 8/10
    3) With You - 9/10
    4) Points of Authority - 8/10
    5) Crawling - 10/10
    6) Runaway - 10/10
    7) By Myself - 10/10
    8) In The End - 9/10
    9) A Place For My Head - 9/10
    10) Forgotten - 9/10
    11) Cure For the Itch - 10/10
    12) Pushing Me Away - 8/10

    Total: 109/120 - 90%


    Meteora:

    Don't Stay: 9/10
    Somewhere I Belong: 10/10
    Lying From You: 8/10
    Hit The Floor: 8/10
    Easier To Run: 8/10
    Faint: 7/10
    Figure .09: 10/10
    Breaking The Habit: 9/10
    From The Inside: 10/10
    Nobody's Listening: 9/10
    Session: 10/10
    Numb: 9/10

    Total: 107/120 - 89%

    Minutes To Midnight:

    1) Wake - 9/10
    2) Given Up - 8/10
    3) Leave Out All The Rest - 10/10
    4) Bleed It Out - 8/10
    5) Shadow of the Day - 8/10
    6) What I've Done - 9/10
    7) Hands Held High - 10/10
    8) No More Sorrow - 7/10
    9) Valentine's Day - 9/10
    10) In Between - 5/10
    11) In Pieces - 9/10
    12) The Little Things Give You Away - 7/10

    Total: 99/120 - 82%


    A Thousand Suns:

    1) The Requiem/The Radiance - 8/10
    2) Burning In the Skies - 8/10
    3) Empty Spaces/When They Come For Me - 8/10
    4) Robot Boy - 7/10
    5) Jornada Del Muerto - 8/10
    6) Waiting For the End - 8/10
    7) Blackout - 9/10
    8) Wretches and Kings - 7/10
    9) Wisdom, Justice, and Love/Iridescent - 9/10
    10) Fallout/The Catalyst - 7/10
    11) The Messenger - 8/10

    Total: 87/110 - 79%


    Living Things:

    1) Lost in the Echo - 9/10
    2) In My Remains - 9/10
    3) Burn It Down - 2/10
    4) Lies Greed Misery - 4/10
    5) I'll Be Gone - 8/10
    6) Castle of Glass - 10/10
    7) Victimized - 9/10
    8) Roads Untraveled - 10/10
    9) Skin to Bone - 9/10
    10) Until It Breaks - 9/10
    11) Tinfoil - 7/10
    12) Powerless - 9/10

    Total: 93/120 - 77%

    But in the end for me it goes

    Meteora > Hybrid Theory > Minutes To Midnight & Living Things > A Thousand Suns
     
    Last edited: Aug 26, 2012
  8. #8
    Blake

    Blake Leave a Trace LPA Super Member

    Joined:
    Mar 25, 2012
    Messages:
    8,284
    Likes Received:
    2,238



    I find it funny how some people's aren't turning out the way they would order them, I guess that's bond to happen so it's more funny that mine turned out the exact order
     
  9. #9
    Avo

    Avo Don't Stop Running

    Joined:
    Jul 19, 2010
    Messages:
    911
    Likes Received:
    39



    Hybrid Theory EP
    Carousel: 5/10
    Technique: 6/10
    Step Up: 5/10
    And One: 9/10
    High Voltage: 7/10
    Part Of Me: 8/10
    Ambient: 9/10

    Rating: 70%

    Hybrid Theory
    Papercut: 10/10
    One Step Closer: 2/10
    With You: 9/10
    Points Of Authority: 6/10
    Crawling: 7/10
    Runaway: 4/10
    By Myself: 4/10
    In The End: 7/10
    A Place For My Head: 7/10
    Forgotten: 9/10
    Cure for the Itch: 6/10
    Pushing Me Away: 8/10

    Rating: 66%

    Meteora
    Foreward/Don't Stay: 2/10
    Somewhere I Belong: 3/10
    Lying From You: 6/10
    Hit The Floor: 0/10
    Easier To Run: 7/10
    Faint: 9/10
    Figure .09: 4/10
    Breaking The Habit: 8/10
    From The Inside: 6/10
    Nobody's Listening: 4/10
    Session: 9/10
    Numb: 3/10

    Rating: 51%

    Minutes To Midnight
    Wake: 6/10
    Given Up: 4/10
    Leave Out All The Rest: 8/10
    Bleed it Out: 9/10
    Shadow Of The Day: 8/10
    What I've Done: 3/10
    Hands Held High: 10/10
    No More Sorrow: 3/10
    Valentines Day: 9/10
    In Between: 10/10
    In Pieces: 8/10
    The Little Things Give You Away: 10/10

    Rating: 73%

    A Thousand Suns
    The Requiem: 10/10
    The Radiance: 6/10
    Burning In The Skies: 8/10
    Empty Spaces/When They Come For Me: 10/10
    Robot Boy: 9/10
    Jornada Del Muerto: 10/10
    Waiting For The End: 10/10
    Blackout: 10/10
    Wretches And Kings: 6/10
    Wisdom, Justice, and Love: 10/10
    Iridescent: 9/10
    Fallout: 9/10
    The Catalyst: 10/10
    The Messenger: 8/10

    Rating: 89%

    Living Things
    Lost in the Echo: 3/10
    In My Remains: 8/10
    Burn It Down: 3/10
    Lies Greed Misery: 4/10
    I'll Be Gone: 3/10
    Castle of Glass: 9/10
    Victimized: 8/10
    Roads Untraveled: 10/10
    Skin to Bone: 9/10
    Until It Breaks: 10/10
    Tinfoil: 10/10
    Powerless: 7/10

    Rating: 70%

    1. A Thousand Suns 89%
    2. Minutes To Midnight 73%
    3. Living Things 70%
    4. Hybrid Theory EP 70%
    5. Hybrid Theory 66%
    6. Meteora 51%

    Same order that I'd rate them too.
     
  10. #10
    Bennington_Hahn

    Bennington_Hahn This goes out to everybody still hatin' LPA VIP

    Joined:
    Apr 6, 2007
    Messages:
    1,255
    Likes Received:
    5



    I was thinking of doing this, but heck that'll be too obsessive xD

    For me, I would guess with the HT-EP in the equation, my album rank would be:

    HT EP > ATS > HT > MTM > LT > M
     
  11. #11
    lpxerotheoryfan

    lpxerotheoryfan Can you do it like this?

    Joined:
    Jul 12, 2008
    Messages:
    212
    Likes Received:
    0



    I'm taking the easy way out lol.

    Hybrid Theory>Minutes to Midnight>Reanimation>Hybrid Theory EP>Living Things>Meteora>A Thousand Suns
     
  12. #12
    Atticus

    Atticus Bullets lance the bravest lungs

    Joined:
    Jul 27, 2010
    Messages:
    1,395
    Likes Received:
    330



    I did this for myself shortly after Living Things had time to sink in, just so I could have a definitive list.

    HYBRID THEORY - EP
    Carousel: 7/10
    Technique: 4/10
    Step Up: 5.5/10
    And One: 9.3/10
    High Voltage: 3.5/10
    Part Of Me: 8/10
    Ambient: 3/10

    Overall: 57.5%

    HYBRID THEORY
    Papercut: 9.2/10
    One Step Closer: 7.7/10
    With You: 8/10
    Points Of Authority: 7.9/10
    Crawling: 4/10
    Runaway: 7.6/10
    By Myself: 7.3/10
    In The End: 8.5/10
    A Place For My Head: 9.6/10
    Forgotten: 8.5/10
    Cure For The Itch: 7/10
    Pushing Me Away: 8/10

    Overall: 78%

    METEORA
    Foreword/Don't Stay: 8/10
    Somewhere I Belong: 7.4/10
    Lying From You: 8.6/10
    Hit The Floor: 6.7/10
    Easier To Run: 7.8/10
    Faint: 9.6/10
    Figure.09: 8/10
    Breaking The Habit: 8.7/10
    From The Inside: 9.3/10
    Nobody's Listening: 7/10
    Session: 8.4/10
    Numb: 8/10

    Overall: 81%

    MINUTES TO MIDNIGHT
    Wake: 9/10
    Given Up: 9.2/10
    Leave Out All The Rest: 7.5/10
    Bleed It Out: 8/10
    Shadow Of The Day: 9.5/10
    What I've Done: 8.6/10
    Hands Held High: 8/10
    No More Sorrow: 9.6/10
    Valentine's Day: 8.2/10
    In Between: 6.5/10
    In Pieces: 9.9/10
    The Little Things Give You Away: 10/10

    Overall: 87%

    A THOUSAND SUNS
    The Requiem: 9.5/10
    The Radiance: 8/10
    Burning In The Skies: 8.9/10
    (The Requiem/The Radiance/Burning In The Skies: 9.5/10)
    Empty Spaces: 2/10
    When They Come For Me: 9.5/10
    Robot Boy: 7.7/10
    Jornada Del Muerto: 8.8/10
    Waiting For The End: 9.5/10
    (Jornada Del Muerto/Waiting For The End: 9.7/10)
    Blackout: 10/10
    Wretches And Kings: 8.8/10
    Wisdom, Justice And Love: 4/10
    Iridescent: 9.5/10
    (Wisdom, Justice And Love/Iridescent: 9.8/10)
    Fallout: 9.5/10
    The Catalyst: 9.7/10
    (Fallout/The Catalyst: 10/10)
    The Messenger: 8.8/10

    Overall (Individually): 83%
    Overall (Combining Interludes): 93%

    LIVING THINGS
    Lost In The Echo: 10/10
    In My Remains: 9.5/10
    Burn It Down: 8.6/10
    Lies Greed Misery: 9.4/10
    I'll Be Gone: 8/10
    Castle Of Glass: 9/10
    Victimized: 10/10
    Roads Untraveled: 9.8/10
    Skin To Bone: 8.7/10
    Until It Breaks: 8.8/10
    Tinfoil: 6/10
    Powerless: 9.7/10
    (Tinfoil/Powerless: 10/10)

    Overall (Tinfoil Separate): 90%
    Overall: 93%

    ALBUM RANKING
    1. Living Things
    2. A Thousand Suns
    3. Minutes To Midnight
    4. Meteora
    5. Hybrid Theory

    While it's true that Living Things and A Thousand Suns shared the same score, that was only by taking both albums as a full experience. I had to give the nod to Living Things as it had more songs and thus a greater chance for failure.
     
  13. #13
    iamsatan

    iamsatan Well-Known Member

    Joined:
    Jun 5, 2010
    Messages:
    891
    Likes Received:
    133



    Hybrid Theory EP
    Carousel 7/10
    Step Up 6/10
    And One 8/10
    High Voltage 7/10
    Part Of Me/Ambient 9/10

    Total: 37/50

    Hybrid Theory
    Papercut 10/10
    One Step Closer 6/10
    With You 9/10
    Points Of Authority 7/10
    Crawling 8/10
    Runaway 7/10
    By Myself 9/10
    In The End 9/10
    A Place For My Head 9/10
    Forgotten 9/10
    Pushing Me Away 7/10

    Total: 88/110

    Meteora:
    Don't Stay: 7/10
    Somewhere I Belong: 8/10
    Lying From You: 7/10
    Hit The Floor: 4/10
    Easier To Run: 8/10
    Faint: 9/10
    Figure .09: 8/10
    Breaking The Habit: 10/10
    From The Inside: 7/10
    Nobody's Listening: 7/10
    Numb: 7/10

    72/110

    Minutes To Midnight
    Given Up 7/10
    Leave Out All The Rest 9/10
    Bleed It Out 8/10
    Shadow Of The Day 6/10
    What I've Done 5/10
    Hands Held High 7/10
    No More Sorrow 7/10
    Valentines Day 7/10
    In Between 10/10
    In Pieces 10/10
    The Little Things Give You Away 8/10

    84/110

    A Thousand Suns
    Burning In The Skies 7/10
    When They Come For Me 8/10
    Robot Boy 5/10
    Waiting For The End 10/10
    Blackout 9/10
    Wretches And Kings 7/10
    Iridescent 9/10
    The Catalyst 9/10
    The Messenger 7/10

    71/90

    Living Things:
    LOST IN THE ECHO: 10/10
    IN MY REMAINS: 9/10
    BURN IT DOWN: 6/10
    LIES GREED MISERY: 7/10
    I'LL BE GONE: 5/10
    CASTLE OF GLASS: 10/10
    VICTIMIZED: 7/10
    ROADS UNTRAVELED: 9/10
    SKIN TO BONE: 7/10
    UNTIL IT BREAKS: 8/10
    TINFOIL/POWERLESS: 9/10

    85/110

    1. Hybrid Theory 80%
    2. A Thousand Suns - 78%
    3. Living Things - 77%
    4. Minutes to Midnight - 76%
    5. Hybrid Theory EP - 74%
    6. Meteora - 65%

    I wasn't surprised in the order of albums highest rated to least, but was pretty surprised at how close the scores are.
     
  14. #14
    hawk

    hawk because the internet LPA Super VIP

    Joined:
    Apr 1, 2010
    Messages:
    7,681
    Likes Received:
    32



    Your signature says otherwise.

    --

    Picking only 11 tracks for each album (generally the shortest aren't scored).

    Hybrid Theory
    01. Papercut [7/10]
    02. One Step Closer [8/10]
    03. With You [7/10]
    04. Points Authority [8/10]
    05. Crawling [5/10]
    06. Runaway [7/10]
    07. By Myself [8/10]
    08. In The End [9/10]
    09. A Place For My Head [8/10]
    10. Forgotten [8/10]
    11. Cure for the Itch [---]
    12. Pushing Me Away [7/10]

    82/110 - 75%

    Meteora
    01. Foreword [---]
    02. Don't Stay [7/10]
    03. Somewhere I Belong [7/10]
    04. Lying From You [7/10]
    05. Hit the Floor [8/10]
    06. Easier to Run [8/10]
    07. Faint [7/10]
    08. Figure.09 [8/10]
    09. Breaking the Habit [8/10]
    10. From the Inside [7/10]
    11. Nobody's Listening [7/10]
    12. Session [---]
    13. Numb [6/10]

    80/110 - 73%

    Minutes to Midnight
    01. Wake [---]
    02. Given Up [7/10]
    03. Leave Out All Rest [8/10]
    04. Bleed It Out [7/10]
    05. Shadow of the Day [7/10]
    06. What I've Done [8/10]
    07. Hands Held High [8/10]
    08. No More Sorrow [7/10]
    09. Valentine's Day [7/10]
    10. In Between [8/10]
    11. In Pieces [8/10]
    12. The Little Things Give You Away [8/10]

    83/110 - 75%

    A Thousand Suns
    01. The Requiem [7/10]
    02. The Radiance [---]
    03. Burning in the Skies [8/10]
    04. Empty Spaces [---]
    05. When They Come For Me [9/10]
    06. Robot Boy [8/10]
    07. Jornada del Muerto [10/10]
    08. Waiting for the End [7/10]
    09. Blackout [8/10]
    10. Wretches and Kings [7/10]
    11. Wisdom, Justice, and Love [---]
    12. Iridescent [7/10]
    13. Fallout [---]
    14. The Catalyst [9/10]
    15. The Messenger [6/10]

    86/110 - 78%

    LIVING THINGS
    01. LOST IN THE ECHO [8/10]
    02. IN MY REMAINS [7/10]
    03. BURN IT DOWN [7/10]
    04. LIES GREED MISERY [7/10]
    05. I'LL BE GONE [8/10]
    06. CASTLE OF GLASS [9/10]
    07. VICTIMIZED [8/10]
    08. ROADS UNTRAVELED [7/10]
    09. SKIN TO BONE [7/10]
    10. UNTIL IT BREAKS [10/10]
    11. TINFOIL [---]
    12. POWERLESS [9/10]

    87/110 - 79%

    LIVING THINGS -> A Thousand Suns -> Minutes to Midnight -> Hybrid Theory -> Meteora. Exactly how I'd put it.
     
  15. #15
    deftonesfan867

    deftonesfan867 976-EVIL

    Joined:
    Apr 5, 2010
    Messages:
    1,270
    Likes Received:
    8



    ATS>LT>MTM>HT>Meteora.
     
  16. #16
    Filip

    Filip god break down the door LPA Contributor

    Joined:
    May 23, 2012
    Messages:
    10,879
    Likes Received:
    1,493



    HYBRID THEORY:
    Papercut - 9/10
    One Step Closer - 9/10
    With You - 7/10
    Points Of Authority - 10/10
    Crawling - 10/10
    Runaway - 8/10
    By Myself - 8/10
    In The End - 8/10
    A Place For My Head - 10/10
    Forgotten - 7/10
    Cure For The Itch - 6/10
    Pushing Me Away - 9/10

    Final score: 101/120 = 84%

    METEORA:
    Forgotten/Don't Stay - 7/10
    Somewhere I Belong - 7/10
    Lying From You - 9/10
    Hit The Floor - 8/10
    Easier To Run - 7/10
    Faint - 8/10
    Figure .09 - 9/10
    Breaking The Habit - 10/10
    From The Inside 8/10
    Nobody's Listening 5/10
    Session - 9/10
    Numb - 7/10

    Final Score: 91/120 = 76%

    MINUTES TO MIDNIGHT:
    Wake - 8/10
    Given Up - 8/10
    Leave Out All The Rest - 8/10
    Bleed It Out - 8/10
    Shadow Of The Day - 8/10
    What I've Done - 10/10
    Hands Held High - 7/10
    No More Sorrow- 9/10
    Valentine's Day - 9/10
    In Between - 7/10
    In Pieces - 9/10
    The Little Things Give You Away - 9/10

    Final score: 100/120 = 83%

    A THOUSAND SUNS:
    [Interludes] - 10/10
    Burning In The Skies - 10/10
    When They Come For Me - 9/10
    Robot Boy - 9/10
    Waiting For The End - 9/10
    Blackout - 9/10
    Wretches And Kings - 10/10
    Iridescent - 10/10
    The Catalyst - 10/10
    The Messenger - 9/10

    Final score: 95/10 = 95%

    LIVING THINGS:
    Lost In The Echo - 9/10
    In My Remains - 6/10
    Burn It Down - 6/10
    Lies Greed Misery - 9/10
    I'll Be Gone - 6/10
    Castle Of Glass - 10/10
    Victimized - 9/10
    Roads Untraveled - 9/10
    Skin To Bone - 10/10
    Until It Breaks - 6/10
    Tinfoil/Powerless - 9/10

    Final score: - 89/110 = 81%

    1: A Thousand Suns - 95%
    2: Hybrid Theory - 84%
    3: Minutes To Midnight - 83%
    4: Living Things - 81%
    5: Meteora - 76%
     
  17. #17
    Minus

    Minus ohai LPA Addicted VIP

    Joined:
    Aug 24, 2003
    Messages:
    18,575
    Likes Received:
    1,002



    As I'm on my phone, on hold with IT, I'm going to do the shorthand ranking.

    ATS = Reanimation > LT = MTM = HT > All other LP releases > dirt > the worms inside the dirt > Mr. Popo's stool > Krillin > Batman and Robin starring George Clooney > The Room > The Last Airbender by M. Night Shyamalammadingdong > living in Fort Worth > killing babies > Hitler > literally everything else > Meteora
     
  18. #18
    deftonesfan867

    deftonesfan867 976-EVIL

    Joined:
    Apr 5, 2010
    Messages:
    1,270
    Likes Received:
    8



    [​IMG]
     
  19. #19
    minuteforce

    minuteforce Danny's not here, Mrs. Torrance. LPA Team

    Joined:
    Oct 31, 2004
    Messages:
    12,760
    Likes Received:
    1,782



    I love "Batman & Robin", would rate it way above "dirt" :lol:
     
  20. #20
    Minus

    Minus ohai LPA Addicted VIP

    Joined:
    Aug 24, 2003
    Messages:
    18,575
    Likes Received:
    1,002



    ZOMG A FORT WORTHIAN WHO CAN READ
     

Share This Page