Since I don't think it's actually possible to quantify an opinion using some arbitrary numbers, I'm just gonna do it this way. Reanimation A Thousand Suns Hybrid Theory EP Minutes to Midnight Living Things Meteora Hybrid Theory
A Thousand Suns Living Things Reanimation = Minutes To Midnight Hybrid Theory Meteora Reanimation, MTM and HT are VERY close to being my third favorite so my ranking of those 3 albums tends to change sometimes. Oh c'mon man, The Room isn't THAT bad.
I feel like we've had a million of these threads. Anyways: 01. A Thousand Suns 02. LIVING THINGS 03. Minutes to Midnight 04. Reanimation = Hybrid Theory 05. Meteora
I don´t have the time for ranking every song, so I´ll solve it like many others before me... 1. Meteora (100%) 2. Hybrid Theory (99%) 3. Living Things (93%) 4. Minutes to Midnight (85%) 5. A Thousand Suns (73%)
HYBRID THEORY: Papercut - 9/10 One Step Closer - 10/10 With You - 7/10 Points Of Authority - 10/10 Crawling - 8/10 Runaway - 7/10 By Myself - 8/10 In The End - 10/10 A Place For My Head - 10/10 Forgotten - 10/10 Cure For The Itch - 6/10 Pushing Me Away - 10/10 Final score: 105/120 = 88% METEORA: Foreward/Don't Stay - 9/10 Somewhere I Belong - 8/10 Lying From You - 9/10 Hit The Floor - 8/10 Easier To Run - 8/10 Faint - 10/10 Figure .09 - 10/10 Breaking The Habit - 7/10 From The Inside 8/10 Nobody's Listening 5/10 Session - 7/10 Numb - 9/10 Final Score: 98/120 = 82% MINUTES TO MIDNIGHT: Wake - 7/10 Given Up - 10/10 Leave Out All The Rest - 9/10 Bleed It Out - 7/10 Shadow Of The Day - 9/10 What I've Done - 10/10 Hands Held High - 7/10 No More Sorrow- 9/10 Valentine's Day - 9/10 In Between - 7/10 In Pieces - 8/10 The Little Things Give You Away - 9/10 Final score: 94/120 = 78% A THOUSAND SUNS: Interludes - 8/10 Burning In The Skies - 9/10 When They Come For Me - 9/10 Robot Boy - 7/10 Waiting For The End - 9/10 Blackout - 7/10 Wretches And Kings - 9/10 Iridescent - 9/10 The Catalyst - 10/10 The Messenger - 10/10 Final score: 86/100 = 86% LIVING THINGS: Lost In The Echo - 10/10 In My Remains - 9/10 Burn It Down - 9/10 Lies Greed Misery - 9/10 I'll Be Gone - 9/10 Castle Of Glass - 8/10 Victimized - 9/10 Roads Untraveled - 10/10 Skin To Bone - 8/10 Until It Breaks - 6/10 Tinfoil/Powerless - 10/10 Final score: - 97/110 = 88% 1: Living Things - 88% =: Hybrid Theory - 88% 3: A Thousand Suns - 86% 4: Meteora - 82% 5: Minutes To Midnight - 78%
Krillin! Too soon! This method analyzes the parts, but not the albums as a whole. ...Also, SHAME on everyone who skips the instrumentals in the calculation. Whoever I copied the list from originally is a loser who smells. It's as if they didn't think they counted as music or something. CFTI is an excellent song, jeez. Anyway, Hybrid Theory EP Carousel - 8/10 Technique - 6/10 Step Up - 7/10 And One - 10/10 High Voltage - 6/10 Part Of Me - 10/10 78% Hybrid Theory Papercut - 9/10 One Step Closer - 9/10 With You - 6/10 Points Of Authority - 5/10 Crawling - 8/10 Runaway - 6/10 By Myself - 10/10 In The End - 10/10 A Place For My Head -9/10 Forgotten -9/10 Cure for the Itch - 9/10 Pushing Me Away - 10/10 83% Meteora: Don't Stay: -10/10 Somewhere I Belong: - 9/10 Lying From You: -10/10 Hit The Floor: - 7/10 Easier To Run: -8/10 Faint: - 10/10 Figure .09: - 8/10 Breaking The Habit: - 10/10 From The Inside: - 10/10 Nobody's Listening: -7/10 Session -5/10 Numb: - 4/10 81% Minutes To Midnight Wake - 6/10 Given Up - 2/10 Leave Out All The Rest - 8/10 Bleed It Out - 10/10 Shadow Of The Day -1/10 What I've Done -4/10 Hands Held High -2/10 No More Sorrow - 4/10 Valentines Day - 5/10 In Between - 5/10 In Pieces - 9/10 The Little Things Give You Away -10/10 55% (with NRL 58%) A Thousand Suns The Requiem/The Radiance - 10/10 Burning In The Skies - 10/10 When They Come For Me -10/10 Robot Boy -8/10 Waiting For The End - 9/10 Blackout -10/10 Wretches And Kings - 10/10 Iridescent -10/10 Fallout/The Catalyst -10/10 The Messenger - 6/10 93% Living Things: LOST IN THE ECHO: - 10/10 IN MY REMAINS: -9/10 BURN IT DOWN: - 6/10 LIES GREED MISERY: -5/10 I'LL BE GONE: -1/10 CASTLE OF GLASS: -2/10 VICTIMIZED: -7/10 ROADS UNTRAVELED: -3/10 SKIN TO BONE: -3/10 UNTIL IT BREAKS: -3/10 TINFOIL/POWERLESS: -10/10 (tinfoil by itself would have gotten a 10) 48% Finals: ATS(93) > HT(83) > M(81) > HTEP(78) > MTM(55) > LT(48) only surprise in there was that M beat out HTEP.
HYBRID THEORY: Papercut - 9/10 One Step Closer - 6/10 With You - 9/10 Points Of Authority - 7/10 Crawling - 7/10 Runaway - 6/10 By Myself - 5/10 In The End - 7/10 A Place For My Head - 8/10 Forgotten - 6/10 Cure For The Itch - 5/10 Pushing Me Away - 10/10 Final score: 85/120 = 70.83% METEORA: Forgotten/Don't Stay - 7/10 Somewhere I Belong - 7/10 Lying From You - 9/10 Hit The Floor - 6/10 Easier To Run - 7/10 Faint - 10/10 Figure .09 - 8/10 Breaking The Habit - 10/10 From The Inside 9/10 Nobody's Listening 5/10 Session - 5/10 Numb - 10/10 Final Score: 93/120 = 77.5% MINUTES TO MIDNIGHT: Wake - 7/10 Given Up - 9/10 Leave Out All The Rest - 10/10 Bleed It Out - 9/10 Shadow Of The Day - 7/10 What I've Done - 9/10 Hands Held High - 8/10 No More Sorrow- 10/10 Valentine's Day - 8/10 In Between - 6/10 In Pieces - 8/10 The Little Things Give You Away - 6/10 Final score: 97/120 = 80.83% A THOUSAND SUNS: [Interludes] - 10/10 Burning In The Skies - 9/10 When They Come For Me - 10/10 Robot Boy - 7/10 Waiting For The End - 10/10 Blackout - 9/10 Wretches And Kings - 10/10 Iridescent - 9/10 The Catalyst - 10/10 The Messenger - 8/10 Final score: 92/100 = 92% LIVING THINGS: Lost In The Echo - 7/10 In My Remains - 8/10 Burn It Down - 9/10 Lies Greed Misery - 10/10 I'll Be Gone - 10/10 Castle Of Glass - 10/10 Victimized - 9/10 Roads Untraveled - 7/10 Skin To Bone - 10/10 Until It Breaks - 6/10 Tinfoil - 8/10 Powerless - 10/10 Final score: - 104/120 = 86.7% 1: A Thousand Suns - 92% 2: Living Things - 86.7% 3: Minutes To Midnight - 80.83% 4: Meteora - 77.5% 5: Hybrid Theory - 70.83%
Hybrid Theory EP Carousel 9/10 Step Up 10/10 And One 8/10 High Voltage 4/10 Part Of Me 10/10 Total : 41/50 Hybrid Theory Papercut: 6/10 One Step Closer: 3/10 With You: 10/10 Points Of Authority: 4/10 Crawling: 7/10 Runaway: 9/10 By Myself: 8/10 In The End: 7/10 A Place For My Head: 5/10 Forgotten: 6/10 Cure for the Itch: 8/10 Pushing Me Away: 10/10 Total : 83/120 Meteora: Don't Stay: 5/10 Somewhere I Belong: 7/10 Lying From You: 7/10 Hit The Floor: 8/10 Easier To Run: 10/10 Faint: 10/10 Figure .09: 4/10 Breaking The Habit: 9/10 From The Inside: 8/10 Nobody's Listening: 9/10 Session: 10/10 Numb: 9/10 Total : 96/120 Minutes To Midnight: 1) Wake - 10/10 2) Given Up - 7/10 3) Leave Out All The Rest - 10/10 4) Bleed It Out - 8/10 5) Shadow of the Day - 6/10 6) What I've Done - 9/10 7) Hands Held High - 10/10 8) No More Sorrow - 3/10 9) Valentine's Day - 4/10 10) In Between - 9/10 11) In Pieces - 9/10 12) The Little Things Give You Away - 8/10 Total: 93/120 A Thousand Suns: 1) The Requiem/The Radiance - 6/10 2) Burning In the Skies - 10/10 3) Empty Spaces/When They Come For Me - 7/10 4) Robot Boy - 4/10 5) Jornada Del Muerto - 10/10 6) Waiting For the End - 9/10 7) Blackout - 8/10 8) Wretches and Kings - 9/10 9) Wisdom, Justice, and Love/Iridescent - 8/10 10) Fallout/The Catalyst - 5/10 11) The Messenger - 9/10 Total: 85/110 Living Things: 1) Lost in the Echo - 10/10 2) In My Remains - 10/10 3) Burn It Down - 6/10 4) Lies Greed Misery - 9/10 5) I'll Be Gone - 8/10 6) Castle of Glass - 6/10 7) Victimized - 8/10 8) Roads Untraveled - 5/10 9) Skin to Bone - 6/10 10) Until It Breaks - 10/10 11) Tinfoil - 6/10 12) Powerless - 9/10 Total: 93/120 Hybrid theory EP : 82% Hybrid Theory : 69% Meteora : 80% Minutes to midnight : 77.5% A Thousand Suns : 77.27% Living Things : 77.5% Hybrid theory EP--->Meteora--->Living Things & Minutes to midnight ---->A Thousand Suns----->Hybrid Theory SHOCKED O_O EXTREMELY SHOCKED. What i expected : Meteora---> Living Things----> Hybrid Theory & Hybrid Theory EP. -----> Minutes to midnight ------> A Thousand Suns.
I'm going to do it, just curious about how the album rating will end up Hybrid Theory EP Carousel 8/10 Step Up 8/10 And One 8/10 High Voltage 7/10 Part Of Me/Ambient 9/10 Total: 40/50 Hybrid Theory Papercut 8/10 One Step Closer 9/10 With You 9/10 Points Of Authority 10/10 Crawling 8/10 Runaway 6/10 By Myself 10/10 In The End 7/10 A Place For My Head 10/10 Forgotten 9/10 Cure For The Itch 8/10 Pushing Me Away 9/10 Total: 103/120 Meteora: Don't Stay: 8/10 Somewhere I Belong: 6/10 Lying From You: 8/10 Hit The Floor: 6/10 Easier To Run: 6/10 Faint: 9/10 Figure .09: 10/10 Breaking The Habit: 7/10 From The Inside: 8/10 Nobody's Listening: 7/10 Session: 9/10 Numb: 7/10 91/120 Minutes To Midnight Wake 7/10 Given Up 8/10 Leave Out All The Rest 5/10 Bleed It Out 7/10 Shadow Of The Day 6/10 What I've Done 6/10 Hands Held High 7/10 No More Sorrow 8/10 Valentines Day 7/10 In Between 8/10 In Pieces 9/10 The Little Things Give You Away 10/10 88/120 A Thousand Suns The Requiem 9/10 The Radiance 4/10 Burning In The Skies 6/10 When They Come For Me 9/10 Robot Boy 7/10 Jornada Del Muerto 8/10 Waiting For The End 9/10 Blackout 10/10 Wretches And Kings 8/10 WJL 5/10 Iridescent 6/10 Fallout 2/10 The Catalyst 9/10 The Messenger 7/10 99/150 Living Things: LOST IN THE ECHO 8/10 IN MY REMAINS 7/10 BURN IT DOWN: 5/10 LIES GREED MISERY: 8/10 I'LL BE GONE: 4/10 CASTLE OF GLASS: 7/10 VICTIMIZED: 9/10 ROADS UNTRAVELED: 7/10 SKIN TO BONE: 6/10 UNTIL IT BREAKS: 8/10 TINFOIL: 7/10 POWERLESS: 8/10 84/120 So finally... HT 86 % > HTEP 80% >M : 76% >MTM: 73% > LT 70% > ATS :66% HT and HTEP being my favorite isn't a surprise. Also, if I don't count the interludes, ATS goes up to 79%, which makes it my third favorite LP record, and which makes Living Things my least favorite. Weird...
Well, not sure. Interludes help building a musical landscape and can make a record even better. I simply think the ATS interludes were bad (except Requiem and Jornada), those didn't sound good to my ears.
Hybrid Theory EP Carousel 9/10 Step Up 5/10 And One 10/10 High Voltage 7/10 Part Of Me 9/10 Total : 40/50 Hybrid Theory Papercut: 8/10 One Step Closer: 3/10 With You: 9/10 Points Of Authority: 8/10 Crawling: 5/10 Runaway: 5/10 By Myself: 9/10 In The End: 7/10 A Place For My Head: 8/10 Forgotten: 10/10 Cure for the Itch: 7/10 Pushing Me Away: 9/10 Total : 88/120 Meteora: Don't Stay: 2/10 Somewhere I Belong: 2/10 Lying From You: 3/10 Hit The Floor: 7/10 Easier To Run: 2/10 Faint: 7/10 Figure .09: 5/10 Breaking The Habit: 7/10 From The Inside: 6/10 Nobody's Listening: 5/10 Session: 4/10 Numb: 4/10 Total : 54/120 Minutes To Midnight: 1) Wake - 6/10 2) Given Up - 6/10 3) Leave Out All The Rest - 8/10 4) Bleed It Out - 6/10 5) Shadow of the Day - 6/10 6) What I've Done - 6/10 7) Hands Held High - 9/10 8) No More Sorrow - 5/10 9) Valentine's Day - 8/10 10) In Between - 8/10 11) In Pieces - 9/10 12) The Little Things Give You Away - 9/10 Total: 88/120 A Thousand Suns: 1) The Requiem/The Radiance - 9/10 2) Burning In the Skies - 10/10 3) Empty Spaces/When They Come For Me - 10/10 4) Robot Boy - 9/10 5) Jornada Del Muerto - 9/10 6) Waiting For the End - 9/10 7) Blackout - 10/10 8) Wretches and Kings - 7/10 9) Wisdom, Justice, and Love/Iridescent - 8/10 10) Fallout/The Catalyst - 10/10 11) The Messenger - 8/10 Total: 99/110 Living Things: 1) Lost in the Echo - 7/10 2) In My Remains - 8/10 3) Burn It Down - 7/10 4) Lies Greed Misery - 5/10 5) I'll Be Gone - 6/10 6) Castle of Glass - 9/10 7) Victimized - 7/10 8) Roads Untraveled - 10/10 9) Skin to Bone - 9/10 10) Until It Breaks - 10/10 11) Tinfoil - 3/10 12) Powerless - 8/10 Total: 89/120
Hybrid Theory EP Carousel 9/10 Step Up 10/10 And One 10/10 High Voltage 3/10 Part Of Me 9/10 Total: 41/50 Hybrid Theory Papercut 10/10 One Step Closer 6/10 With You 10/10 Points Of Authority 10/10 Crawling 7/10 Runaway 9/10 By Myself 9/10 In The End 8/10 A Place For My Head 10/10 Forgotten 8/10 Pushing Me Away 9/10 Total: 96/110 Meteora: Don't Stay: 8/10 Somewhere I Belong: 8/10 Lying From You: 10/10 Hit The Floor: 9/10 Easier To Run: 5/10 Faint: 9/10 Figure .09: 9/10 Breaking The Habit: 10/10 From The Inside: 10/10 Nobody's Listening: 6/10 Numb: 1/10 85/110 Minutes To Midnight Given Up 5/10 Leave Out All The Rest 9/10 Bleed It Out 9/10 Shadow Of The Day 2/10 What I've Done 8/10 Hands Held High 8/10 No More Sorrow 7/10 Valentines Day 2/10 In Between 10/10 In Pieces 7/10 The Little Things Give You Away 7/10 74/110 A Thousand Suns Burning In The Skies 9/10 When They Come For Me 8/10 Robot Boy 7/10 Waiting For The End 10/10 Blackout 10/10 Wretches And Kings 10/10 Iridescent 9/10 The Catalyst 10/10 The Messenger 5/10 78/90 Living Things: Lost in the Echo: 10/10 In My Remains: 7/10 Burn It Down: 8/10 Lies Greed Misery: 7/10 I'll Be Gone: 8/10 Castle of Glass: 10/10 Victimized: 10/10 Roads Untraveled: 9/10 Skin to Bone: 10/10 Until It Breaks: 10/10 TINFOIL/POWERLESS: 10/10 99/110
This might change after I edit my post to rate each song on each album, but after listening through Meteora yesterday: 1. Hybrid Theory 2. A Thousand Suns 3. Minutes to Midnight 4. Living Things 5. Meteora