ONE

I cant decide since the KoRn version can only be heard as a live recording but they are both exellent

 

Both are great, but i prefer the KoRn's One. Dont know why, it just rocks

 

Metallica owns....

 

Metallica for sure.

Jonathan Davis can't really reproduce Hetfields voice and especially his emotion. Also, the skipped all the hard parts, especially the hard guitar parts.

Besides, Metallica came up with that song...Korn has never made songs of that level of musical quality.

 

They both SUCK!!!!!!!!!!

 

I think they are both brilliant but i prefer Korn's version. I dunno why but i just think it sounds better............ :angry: AND NONE OF THEM SUCK!!!!!!!!!!

 

hey you should at least support why you think they both suck instead of just saying that they suck

For myself i prefer KoRn's just because i prefer Jon Davis' voice over James Hetfields'.

 

You never learn, do you?


I like Metallica's better.

 

And here's ANOTHER WARNING.

[Edit] Look at that, your third warning. You're banned.

 

Metallica's version.

 

Korn stopped before the mad crazy solo. :wth:

Meh, their cover's not bad, but the original "One" just blows me away and has to be one of my all-time favorite songs.

 

Metallica's One (Live ####: Binge & Purge) > Korn's One (MTVIcon)




no one can take a Metallica song, and make it better. Actually, I don't believe any cover song is better than the original, simply because the original artist had a plan in mind, and it's their own creation.

 

I know a lot of people who will want to shoot me for this, but to put it lightly, let's just say my opinion of Metallica isn't very high. I won't go into details.

Korn's version.

 

They both rock but nothing lives better like the original!

 

Metallica, only because I heard it first.

 

Korn, just because I like Korn better than metallica. Plus, Johnny D makes it sound better

 

Korn!

 

im going for korn as well. i just love john's voice. its 50:50 now.

 

KoRn, because:

1) I love Jon's voice, i just like Hetfield's
2) Nah, Fieldy's bass will always ROCK over any song.

 

we need to get more people to vote...
well korn will always rock so we might accept it