I've been asked to create The Hunting Party thread. Looks like we are going backwards and doing all albums this way. Here are the rules: You can only hurt one song and heal another. One hurt is -1, one heal is +1. Every song starts at 15 points this time around. Songs will be eliminated once they reach 0 points. We want this to be fun but also go fast. If it takes 2 months for every album, the world might end before we finish! If nobody has posted 3 hours after your post, you may hurt/heal again regardless. Keep the same format as last time on how we voted. @ me when a song gets eliminated so I can update the order. Ill be at work a good portion of my life so I may miss when a song is eliminated. Have fun! I have included my first vote in this post. The Hunting Party Keys To The Kingdom- 15 All For Nothing- 15 Guilty All The Same- 15 The Summoning- 15 War- 14 (-1) Wastelands- 15 Until It’s Gone- 15 Rebellion- 15 Mark The Graves- 16 (+1) Drawbar- 15 Final Masquerade- 15 A Line In The Sand- 15 Edit: Everybody, At the end of this give me feedback if you think it can be improved even more. We are experimenting and at the moment I took @Jesse 's new rules from the food edition because I think are great rules. Feedback is welcome and we got 5 more albums and an EP after this to master it UPDATE: Looks like the rules created do not work for a game this active. The goal is to be fast but also fun. New rules effective as of this post: We are going back to time based but you can now vote every 3 hours. If you think this is too short/long, let me know why and we can adjust. Elimination order so far 12. War 11. The Summoning 10. Wastelands 9. Keys to the Kingdom 8. Until It's Gone 7. All For Nothing 6. Guilty All the Same 5. Drawbar 4. Rebellion 3. Mark the Graves 2. A Line in the Sand 1. Final Masquerade
Keys To The Kingdom- 15 All For Nothing- 15 Guilty All The Same- 15 The Summoning- 15 War- 14 Wastelands- 14 (-1) Until It’s Gone- 15 Rebellion- 15 Mark The Graves- 16 Drawbar- 15 Final Masquerade- 16 (+1) A Line In The Sand- 15
Keys To The Kingdom- 15 All For Nothing- 15 Guilty All The Same- 15 The Summoning- 15 War- 14 Wastelands- 13 (-1) Until It’s Gone- 15 Rebellion- 15 Mark The Graves- 16 Drawbar- 16 (+1) Final Masquerade- 16 A Line In The Sand- 15 #WastelandsMustDie (Also can I propose that we decide now to automatically halve all the points when half the songs are eliminated (like we did last time)? Otherwise the numbers will get really large again ).
Keys To The Kingdom- 15 All For Nothing- 15 Guilty All The Same- 15 The Summoning- 15 War- 13 (-1) Wastelands- 13 Until It’s Gone- 15 Rebellion- 15 Mark The Graves- 16 Drawbar- 16 Final Masquerade- 16 A Line In The Sand- 16 (+1)
I think this is an idea that we can play by ear. Because songs only start at 15 and people can post so much, it might not be an issue this time around. If we are down to 4 songs in the 60s again like last time either a mod or I can officially decide to half it if deemed necessary.
Keys To The Kingdom- 15 All For Nothing- 15 Guilty All The Same- 15 The Summoning- 15 War- 12 (-1) Wastelands- 13 Until It’s Gone- 15 Rebellion- 15 Mark The Graves- 16 Drawbar- 16 Final Masquerade- 16 A Line In The Sand- 17 (+1)
Keys To The Kingdom- 15 All For Nothing- 15 Guilty All The Same- 15 The Summoning- 14 (-1) War- 12 Wastelands- 13 Until It’s Gone- 15 Rebellion- 15 Mark The Graves- 16 Drawbar- 16 Final Masquerade- 17 (+1) A Line In The Sand- 17 The Summoning is kind of a filler song and Final Masquerade is one of the best, if not the best, so those are the votes.
Keys To The Kingdom- 15 All For Nothing- 14 (-1) Guilty All The Same- 15 The Summoning- 14 War- 13 (+1) Wastelands- 13 Until It’s Gone- 15 Rebellion- 15 Mark The Graves- 16 Drawbar- 16 Final Masquerade- 17 A Line In The Sand- 17
Keys To The Kingdom- 15 All For Nothing- 14 Guilty All The Same- 15 The Summoning- 14 War- 12 (-1) Wastelands- 13 Until It’s Gone- 15 Rebellion- 15 Mark The Graves- 17 (+1) Drawbar- 16 Final Masquerade- 17 A Line In The Sand- 17
Keys To The Kingdom- 15 All For Nothing- 14 Guilty All The Same- 15 The Summoning- 14 War- 11 (-1) Wastelands- 13 Until It’s Gone- 16 (+1) Rebellion- 15 Mark The Graves- 17 Drawbar- 16 Final Masquerade- 17 A Line In The Sand- 17
Keys To The Kingdom- 15 All For Nothing- 14 Guilty All The Same- 15 The Summoning- 14 War- 10 (-1) Wastelands- 13 Until It’s Gone- 16 (+1) Rebellion- 15 Mark The Graves- 17 Drawbar- 16 Final Masquerade- 18 (+1) A Line In The Sand- 17
Keys To The Kingdom- 15 All For Nothing- 14 Guilty All The Same- 15 The Summoning- 14 War- 9 (-1) Wastelands- 13 Until It’s Gone- 16 Rebellion- 16 (+1) Mark The Graves- 17 Drawbar- 16 Final Masquerade- 18 (+1) A Line In The Sand- 17
Keys To The Kingdom- 15 All For Nothing- 14 Guilty All The Same- 15 The Summoning- 14 War- 8 (-1) Wastelands- 13 Until It’s Gone- 16 Rebellion- 16 (+1) Mark The Graves- 17 Drawbar- 16 Final Masquerade- 19 (+1) A Line In The Sand- 17
Keys To The Kingdom- 15 All For Nothing- 14 Guilty All The Same- 15 The Summoning- 14 War- 7 (-1) Wastelands- 13 Until It’s Gone- 16 Rebellion- 16 Mark The Graves- 17 Drawbar- 16 Final Masquerade- 20 (+1) A Line In The Sand- 17
Keys To The Kingdom- 15 All For Nothing- 14 Guilty All The Same- 15 The Summoning- 13 (-1) War- 7 Wastelands- 13 Until It’s Gone- 16 Rebellion- 16 Mark The Graves- 18 (+1) Drawbar- 16 Final Masquerade- 20 A Line In The Sand- 17
Keys To The Kingdom- 15 All For Nothing- 14 Guilty All The Same- 15 The Summoning- 13 War- 7 Wastelands- 13 Until It’s Gone- 16 Rebellion- 16 Mark The Graves- 18 Drawbar- 17 (+1) Final Masquerade- 20 A Line In The Sand- 16 (-1)
Keys To The Kingdom- 15 All For Nothing- 14 Guilty All The Same- 15 The Summoning- 13 War- 6 (-1) Wastelands- 13 Until It’s Gone- 16 Rebellion- 16 Mark The Graves- 19 (+1) Drawbar- 17 Final Masquerade- 20 A Line In The Sand- 16