I don't get how people can say it's superior to What I've Done... The lyrics in WID blow this one out of the water, the delivery from Chester is great in both, the mixing is so much clearer in WID, and the general quality of the music is infinitely better in WID. You have the perfect intro, the guitars that come in and then die out perfectly, a great bridge, and a perfect outro. I think people look at it less favourably now because songs like New Divide (which still is awesome) and BID copied the formula. Until it's gone neither has the lyrics, the great mixing, or the musical variety to be better. HOWEVER I am not dissing Until It's Gone. It still packs a punch, I love hte heavyness, and think some of the quieter moments are lovely too. Just not quite in the amazing category.